Actions

User talk

The Kinks::Magioladitis

::concepts

October::small    Style::silktork    Color::bgwhite    November::index    There::thanks    Resolved::template

The Kinks Hi. In your edit on The Kinks article you changed the order of some of the inline cites. It's not an issue, I'm just curious as to the thinking behind the rearrangement because normally cites are arranged in the order of the statements they cover in the sentence as this makes it easy for checking, but your edit changed the logical order to something apparently more random. SilkTork ✔Tea time 06:18, 28 October 2015 (UTC)

SilkTork I changed them in a way that references are given in increasing order i.e. [1][3][2] changes to [1][2][3]. -- Magioladitis (talk) 06:20, 28 October 2015 (UTC)
OK. But I think what I'm curious about is why? SilkTork ✔Tea time 06:27, 28 October 2015 (UTC)
There is another user who has queried the sorting Wikipedia_talk:AutoWikiBrowser/General_fixes#ReorderReferences. I expect that fix has been there a long time, so the rationale may be hard to track down. It may be worth having a discussion about it to see what the consensus is. I suppose one argument in favour of it would be that if people are going to check all the cites at the end of the sentence, and the cites are numerically close together (12, 14, 17, for example), they might find it easier to memorise the number sequence and then check them off one by one rather than going back to the text to find the next cite. SilkTork ✔Tea time 08:00, 29 October 2015 (UTC)
SilkTork thanks for taking some time to check it. I am not references expert. The main argument was/is that since an article is edited by multiple people there is no way to set a "sort by importance/relevance" criterion when adding references because anyone may go and add a reference after or before the existing references. Still, you can seperate the references by adding a comment between them and then AWB won't change the reference order. I hope I was helpful. Thanks again. -- Magioladitis (talk) 10:09, 29 October 2015 (UTC)

I'll copy this over to the AWB talkpage. SilkTork ✔Tea time 13:04, 29 October 2015 (UTC)


User talk:Magioladitis sections
Intro   Welcome back   Invisible characters   \"Clarification needed\" template    Farshid Delshad's bio    A cup of tea for you!   [[User_talk:Magioladitis?section=_Phabricator_task_phab:T100234_| Phabricator task phab:T100234 ]]   Yobot broke a timeline image?    Yobot \"corrected\" incorrectly   Dupe refs  Counter hypothesis   Bug? strange removal of bracket   The Kinks   AWB \"cleanup\" breakage    A barnstar for you!    what are the invisible characters of the Duchere article    Removal of middot escape codes    WikiProject templates    5 Million: We celebrate your contribution   Wikipedia talk:AutoWikiBrowser/General fixes   Reference errors on 2 November   

The Kinks
PREVIOUS: Bug? strange removal of bracket NEXT: AWB \"cleanup\" breakage
<<>>